So in spite of the original notice
that indicated it would stay open, the Radio Shack at 700 South and
State here in SLC is closing (i.e. it's worse than they originally
announced). 2017 retail bankruptcies already outnumber 2016. The distressed retailer list is growing rapidly. But Forbes thinks things are fine.
There are good reasons for this. First, Paula Rosenblum is the sort of
member of my age group that gives my age group a bad name. The way she
poo-poos the effect of on-line shopping is both condescending and
absurd. A nonscientific sampling consisting of my four kids finds a
unanimous preference for shopping online, and one of them is in retail.
Nonscientific, but they're also among the least tech-oriented of their
peers. That's Trouble with a capital T, and Forbes gets a
capital F for ignoring it. Then Rosenblum doubles down with all the
glorious things retailers are doing to bring shoppers back, including
the mall redesigns. Earth to Paula: First tell me how this fits the
financing models for these enterprises (It doesn't.), then tell me how
it gets past the fact that it is aimed at a clientele that is dying (It doesn't.).
There is an even bigger reason Forbes is
taking this position: Steve Forbes is taking this position. Why?
Well, he's part of that dying off generation that thinks mall shopping
is cool (or in his case that sending a servant to do mall shopping for
you is cool). But also, he can't see any of it. As fewer people are
able to consume, retail becomes increasingly dominated by custom-made
products sold in controlled-access locations or even privately. This is
the world Steve Forbes knows, it's working just fine for him, and so no
problem. But if you consider dead real estate and vanishing jobs a
problem, then you might have to differ with him. I do.
No comments:
Post a Comment